The social media revolution (in 15 minutes)

PR is Dead
April 10, 2007, 4:26 pm
Filed under: My stuff

I have written this as a follow-on / adjunct to the piece I wrote on the future of advertising – and also as a build to this article by Dan Greenfield. I have decided to call it PR is dead shamelessly following the link-baiting success of a piece also posted today called Microsoft is Dead.

My view would be that PR doesn’t have a future collectively speaking. Defining PR has always been difficult, and there is no other communications discipline which encompasses such a wide range of specialisms. There is a tenuous glue which holds the bits of PR together, which is either the fact that it isn’t advertising, or the fact that it operates primarily in non-owned or controlled channels. This isn’t strong glue – especially since operating in a non-owned channel is now where everyone is headed.

There are three forces conspiring to dissolve PR. The first is the subject that increasingly comes up whenever PR people are gathered together – eloquently expressed in this piece by Matt Shaw – but which could be summarised as the statement that “everyone is a PR agency now”. The advertising agencies and especially the media agencies are now colonising our patch. But before we develop too sharp a sense of outrage at this fact, it is worth remembering that PR people have no automatic rights of ownership here – you could easily say that the only reason we have ended-up on this patch is because no one else has seen it as desirable real estate.

Both advertising agencies and media agencies are currently limited in their ability to “do” PR. In short, ad agencies don’t really get it yet and are still chained to expensive creative dinosaurs and media agencies don’t know how to create their own ideas, they just know how to sponsor other peoples’ ideas. But, especially in consumer brand areas, they command the heights through their share of budget / client attention and superior measurement metrics. They will learn how to do pull, rather push, communications, very quickly. (Or to be more precise – how to do “Up” rather than “Out” type of communications, accepting the consumers are in control of what information they pull “Down”).

Once everyone is on the PR patch, you could say that is a good thing – a victory for PR. To paraphrase the words of Lou Capozzi, the zero will have been stuck on the PR budget, but will it still actually be a PR budget and will PR still be seen as a separate discipline? And will the people currently in control of the PR budget now be in control of this larger one? Probably not in my view.

The second – which hasn’t been debated enough, in my opinion – concerns the role for PR in a world of transparency. Like it or not, PR has always been about creating and operating in a zone that sits between the messy reality of a brand or business and its perception by its audiences. That isn’t to say it is about spin, manipulation or deception (although it often is) – but more about stage management, direction and presentation. The issue now is that this space is being squeezed and the barricade that PR constructed to protect image and reputation is being stormed. The Public is not going to need or tolerate the presence of intermediaries to manage their Relations with brands and businesses. At this point I will have no truck with anyone who says good PR is always about being open, honest and transparent and there is no role for spin and “the dark arts” of PR. There is a world of difference between facts and objective realities – and the presentation and perception of those facts and realities. And this isn’t the world of lying – but it is the world of PR. Anyone who denies this is the case either has their head in the sand, up somewhere else where the sun don’t shine or hasn’t been in the PR business for any length of time.

My view is that as this space disappears, PR will be more about shaping how companies respond to incoming communications and manage upwards content feeds. But whether this will really still be PR and best managed by the people formerly known as PRs will be anyone’s guess.

The third force which is dissolving PR is the issue I referred to in my piece on the future of advertising – namely the fact that the whole market will re-align around specialists and aggregators. Some PR agencies may evolve into aggregators – they have a better chance of doing it that most ad agencies – but for the rest, PR will fall apart into the collection of specialisms it really is and be on the rail along with a whole range of other specialisms (including advertising).

So the death of PR as a discipline is both good and bad news for those people in it. The skills PR people have will be in increasing demand, but the houses we currently live in will be knocked down and we will have to find new places to live.
Technorati Tags: , ,


21 Comments so far
Leave a comment

My take:

Kind regards,

Amanda Chapel

Comment by Amanda Chapel

[…] PR is dead: The social media revolution (in 15 minutes) Was it Shel Israel who blogged recently on how sick he was of these “X is Dead” posts? […]

Pingback by media mindshare: on news, technology & media relations links for 2007-04-16 «

This is very insightful, there is now doubt that the PR agenda is no longer solely in the hands of PR professionals.
The search marketing fraternity is taking a lead here I believe, this is the basis of my whitepaper Public Relations Versus Search Marketing – Clash or Collaboration.

Comment by Daryl Willcox

PR is dead

Unter diesem provokanten Titel ist seit über einer Woche ein Posting von Richard Stacy aus seinem Blog „the social media revolution“ unter den beliebtesten Blogbeiträgen auf NewPR zu finden.
PR hat gemäss Stacy keine Zukunft mehr. Ein Grund für…

Trackback by Crossmediale Kommunikation

I love it. Honesty and transparency. It means half of the PR industry is going to have to be replaced!

Comment by Geoff Livingston

I’ve been on this bandwagon since the first boom and I’m happy to see more people carrying the charge. It is all about social Darwinism and shock therapy is the only way to get PR to listen.

PR has hidden behind a cloak of deception and hype and it is now getting yanked into the brave new world of transparancy.

New PR is the difference between spin and evangelism, and broadcasting versus participation.

It’s going to get messy.

Comment by Brian Solis

[…] The social media revolution (in 15 minutes) Another chime of the death knell. Personally, I find this a bit pretentious, but let’s see what you think. (tags: PR social+media) […]

Pingback by » Blog Archive » links for 2007-04-27

Well i think PR is important, but over estimated.
relevancy help me outrank many websites with higher PR.

Comment by Buy Acomplia - HenryBloom

[…] PR is dead – a build on the post about advertising – essentially a piece on the future of PR, but with a more controversial title […]

Pingback by Links to previous posts « Richard Stacy @ Stacy Consulting

current required for rc car


Trackback by current required for rc car

ayden north carolina car insurance


Trackback by ayden north carolina car insurance

big cunt lips


Trackback by big cunt lips

[…] donc beaucoup plus envie de dire “PR is alive” que “PR is dead”. Evidemment tout ce que je dis repose sur l’idée des relations publiques au sens noble du […]

Pingback by 10 raisons pour lesquelles les RP sont le meilleur de la communication online « INTERNET & OPINION

[…] PR is dead […]

Pingback by Directory of dead communications channels « Advertising Agencies Directory

[…] PR is dead […]

Pingback by Directory of dead communications channels

Thank you a lot for giving everyone a very marvellous possiblity to read critical reviews from this web site. It is often very good and full of a good time for me and my office colleagues to visit your web site a minimum of thrice every week to see the latest items you will have. And of course, I am also certainly fulfilled considering the superb things you serve. Some 3 facts in this article are clearly the most impressive I have had.

Comment by Josephine Tennison

blue cross blue cross health insurance quotes oregon

PR is Dead | The social media revolution (in 15 minutes)

Trackback by blue cross blue cross health insurance quotes oregon

Terrific work! That is the kind of information that should be
shared across the net. Shame on Google for now not positioning this
post higher! Come on over and seek advice from my website .
Thanks =)

Comment by Advertising Agency

Thanks to my father who stated to me concerning this web site, this website is really awesome.

Comment by 5-htp

cv services new plymouth

PR is Dead | The social media revolution (in 15 minutes)

Trackback by cv services new plymouth

machine a sous silent run

PR is Dead | The social media revolution (in 15 minutes)

Trackback by machine a sous silent run

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: